Response To: "Umar wished that he was Faeces"

A response to "The Shi'ite Offensive", their article can be found here.

The proponents referenced a tradition reported by Abu Nu`aym al-Asbahani in Hilyat al‑Awliya. Nonetheless, the route of transmission for this report is defective, as Juwaibir bin Sa`id is deemed an abandoned transmitter, rendering this report unsuitable for use as evidence. In Mizan al-`I`tidal, al-Dhahabi documents the assessments of hadith authorities who have criticised Juwaibir bin Sa`id:

Translation: "ibn Ma`in said: He is nothing [...] al-Nasa`i, al-Daraqutni and others have said: He is matruk al-hadith."

End.